“I want nothing more than to win.”
The words of Elise Testone, one of the frontrunners in the race to be the American Idol.
While this sentiment is ubiquitous in both singing competitions, American Idol and The Voice, there are undeniable differences between the two shows.
For one: Contestants on American Idol can actually sing.
There is no doubt that contestants on The Voice are talented. But the caliber of vocal ability on American Idol is unmatched and incomparable to lesser shows such as the Voice. The long, arduous audition process of American Idol ensures that only the elite of vocalists make it to the live shows. Those that are cut? They try out for The Voice.
Number two: Ryan Seacrest is simply better than Carson Daly. And even Carson Daly knows it.
The host is an integral part of a show. They get the most camera time since they are responsible for carrying the show along. Because they must be able to maximize their charisma in the short sentences they use to introduce each act during an episode, only the most exceptional of individuals can successfully host a show.
Lastly, American Idol, ten years and counting, is more skillfully organized.
With 8 more years on the air than The Voice, American Idol has honed its show to near-perfection. Every single phase of the show, from auditions to live shows, is strategically planned and increasingly captivating. The Voice, however, gradually loses steam as the show progresses. The only thing that really sets The Voice apart is the blind auditions, in which judges backs are turned against the contestant, because it builds the suspense that The Voice lacks later in the live shows.
Personally, I saw so much promise in The Voice until the live shows started this week. It has lost all credibility and I refuse to put my ears through the torment of another terrible rendition of a Maroon 5 song.
Picture Idol’s 16-year-old Jessica Sanchez facing Voice‘s 16-year-old Rae Lynn singing against each other like in the infamous Battle Rounds of The Voice… Best of luck to you, Rae Lynn.
