Why Red Dead Redemption 2 is a masterpiece of a video game 

Arthur Morgan in the wilderness. Illustration by Kevin Tran.

By Kevin Tran

Disclaimer: This article has spoilers for the Red Dead Redemption 2 story mode.

Imagine finding yourself in a world so rich in detail that every mountain, river and character feels as real as your own surroundings. Each moment embraces you into the beauty of the wilderness. 

Red Dead Redemption 2 captures this feeling completely, presenting a masterpiece of storytelling and immersion that turns every interaction and landscape into a living work of art.

The story

The story follows Arthur Morgan, a deeply conflicted and complex character. He serves as the right-hand man of the Van der Linde gang led by Dutch Van Der Linde. Arthur and his gang do whatever they can to survive as outlaws in the harsh Wild West in 1899. 

Life on the run is anything but easy. The gang is constantly hunted by relentless lawmen and rival gangs like the O’Driscolls, their every move followed by danger. As they travel from town to town and hideout to hideout, the gang faces increasingly difficult choices for survival, whether it be pulling dangerous heists or confronting rival gangs to gain enough money and resources they desperately need. 

As pressure continues to mount, Arthur’s journey is a powerful story of survival, loyalty and self-discovery. This story is one of the most compelling in gaming history, as it delves into the struggles of a group of people cast out by society, left with no choice but to face the harsh realities of their world. 

Arthur Morgan: the perfect protagonist

This game is brought to life by Arthur Morgan, whose character is nothing short of extraordinary due to his depth, moral complexity and capacity for change. At the start of the story, Arthur is a dedicated enforcer, completely loyal to Dutch and the gang’s way of life without hesitation. 

However, as the story progresses, Dutch becomes more paranoid as his plans increasingly fail. Instead of taking responsibility for his mistakes, he starts blaming others, convinced that his struggles are because of “traitors.”

Arthur, initially loyal to Dutch, begins to feel troubled by Dutch’s new character. As Dutch’s paranoia grows over the story, Arthur starts to question his leader’s poor decisions. He starts to see cracks in Dutch as a leader and the gang’s unity. 

This shift shows Arthur’s depth as a character, showcasing his ability to reflect on his actions and those of his leader. His growing distrust of his leader demonstrates Arthur’s evolving desire to do what is right, even as his gang falls apart.

This growing disillusionment with Dutch is just the beginning of Arthur’s transformation. Early on in the story, Arthur is tasked with collecting a debt from Thomas Downes, a desperate man who cannot repay the money he owes to the gang. Arthur chose to use physical violence to make him pay his debt, unaware that Downes was very ill with tuberculosis (TB) — a disease Arthur contrasted during their close encounter.

Arthur’s health deteriorates throughout the story. His worsening cough and growing weakness mirror his inner struggle. Arthur finally realizes his illness when a doctor diagnoses him with TB.

After being diagnosed with TB and realizing he doesn’t have much longer to live, Arthur begins to reflect on his mortality and the consequences of his life as an outlaw. He shifts towards helping others, particularly John Marston and his family, one of his gang members, ensuring that they have a safe and better future.

His illness isn’t just a random plot twist — it’s a pivotal moment showing Arthur’s extraordinary character development. Arthur contracting tuberculosis is a direct consequence of his violent and morally conflicted lifestyle, forcing him to confront the real cost of his choices.

The graphics and wildlife

Red Dead Redemption 2’s graphics are one of its most breathtaking features, immersing players in a world that feels alive. Every landscape is beautifully rendered, from the high mountains blanketed in snow to the lush forests teeming with wildlife, creating a visual masterpiece. The visuals resemble the harsh Wild West, from the barren, desolate landscapes reflecting the game’s outlaw lifestyle.

The wildlife makes the world feel even more alive. With over 200 species of animals, Players can hunt deer in the dense woods, encounter bears in the mountains or watch eagles soar across the skies. Even the smaller details, like rabbits darting through meadows or raccoons scavenging at night, add to the sense of immersion. 

The game’s lighting adds another layer of magic. With warm golden sunsets resembling peace and stormy skies building up tension, the game’s lighting plays a beautiful emotional tone in the story.

This attention to detail allows players to feel fully immersed in Arthur’s world, making his story all the more impactful. 

Conclusion

Red Dead Redemption 2 is an experience that stays with you long after you put down your controller. Arthur Morgan’s story teaches us the power of reflection, redemption and doing what’s right, even when it’s too late. The game creates a world that feels alive and meaningful.

It’s a journey that hooks you in, reminding you why storytelling in games can be so powerful.