By Andrew Georgy
The holiday season has arrived, bringing with it the old-tale debate between Christmas and Thanksgiving; some prefer the large gathering because of family, while others like the traditions and meaningfulness behind Christmas. Yet the feud is only propelled by extreme turkey-lovers; in reality, Christmas beats Thanksgiving in almost every category.
Food
As one of the most important categories, traditional dishes unite us during these festive holidays. Let’s start with the obvious: Thanksgiving food is more iconic and tasteful than Christmas food. Turkey, mashed potatoes and gravy are an unbeatable combination, while Christmas cookies tend to be too sweet. In fact, if you’ve ever been to a large Christmas gathering, you’ll notice that Thanksgiving food is common to see at the dinner table.
“But what about eggnog and gingerbread houses?” you might ask. While eggnog is popular, it’s more infamous for its weird taste rather than being a quality drink. Gingerbread houses, however, are fun to make but require too much creativity and crafting skills for most people’s liking. Besides, who eats their own gingerbread house?
Music
Think of the last Thanksgiving song you’ve ever heard. Can’t recall anything? How about the last Christmas song you listened to? If I had a penny for every time I heard “All I Want for Christmas Is You” when walking into a department store, I’d have two dollars, which doesn’t seem like much until you realize I’ve heard it over 200 times in just the past couple of years. And that’s only counting in-store; whether it’s family gatherings, malls or even in commercials, we hear and know most Christmas songs by heart. It’s not just about the lyrics; the festive spirit and memories I recall whenever I hear “Jingle Bells” can’t be compared to whatever this is (I seriously don’t know whether to be appalled or dying from laughter).
Presents
No one gives presents for Thanksgiving. Sure, great deals are going around, but you’re most likely forced into buying your own gifts. While Christmas presents depend on your family and friends, you’re hitting the jackpot nine times out of ten, whether it’s a new PS5, iPhone 16 or electric bike.
Mascots
You are out of your mind if you think a turkey is a better mascot than Mr. Jolly himself. While turkeys do get pardoned, Santa Claus is S-tier when it comes to childhood and stories. You hung stockings, left him milk and cookies and even sent letters to the North Pole, hoping your Christmas list was answered. In fact, I’d argue Santa’s reindeer are more iconic than turkeys (you know Dasher and Dancer and Prancer and Vixen but I bet you can’t name a single turkey). Additionally, you can hang up a Christmas tree, but it’s highly uncommon to see someone have a turkey lying around in their backyard (probably for ethical purposes).
Influence and popularity
Not only is Christmas the most popular holiday globally, (even most non-Christian nations still observe it) but it also symbolizes the birth of Jesus, an important historical and religious figure. It influences many denominations of Christianity, the most widespread religion, and it’s usually viewed as a time of giving to the less fortunate or charities (ironic considering the whole purpose of Thanksgiving is to be thankful and giving). Additionally, almost no other country celebrates Thanksgiving, meaning its significance worldwide is almost non-existent.
Conclusion
Although Thanksgiving is important and memorable in its own ways, there’s no denying that Christmas is the most impactful, famous and joyful holiday. Billions of people celebrate it; you get free presents, and the music, traditions and mascots are overall world-renowned. And before you try arguing with me, think of this: do you prefer a one-week or a two-week school break?
